Indiana University study shines new light on consequences of preterm births
Comprehensive study of the records of 3.3 million children used sibling-comparison approach to assess preterm birth’s impact on mortality, psychiatric, educational and social problems
BLOOMINGTON, Ind. — An unprecedented study of preterm birth suggests that only some of the problems previously associated with preterm birth are actually caused by preterm birth itself.
The new study by Indiana University Bloomington researchers confirms the strong link between preterm birth and the risk of infant and young adult death, autism and ADHD. But it also suggests that other threats that have been closely tied to the issue, such as severe mental illness, learning problems, suicide and economic woes, may instead be more closely related to other conditions that family members share.
“The study confirms the degree to which preterm birth is a major public health concern and strongly supports the need for social services that reduce the incidence of preterm birth,” said lead author Brian D’Onofrio, associate professor in the Department of Psychological and Brain Sciences at Indiana University Bloomington. “Yet, the findings also suggest the need to extend services to all siblings in families with an offspring born preterm. In terms of policy, it means that the entire family, including all of the siblings, is at risk.”
The study, “Preterm birth and mortality and morbidity: A population-based quasi-experimental study,” was published today in JAMA Psychiatry. Co-authors include medical researchers from Karolinska Institutet in Stockholm.
In what is thought to be the largest population-based study of preterm births to date, the researchers looked at records of 3.3 million children born in Sweden between 1973 and 2008. Using a sibling-comparison approach and considering a broad continuum of premature gestational ages, the study examined the associations between preterm birth and mortality, psychological health, educational outcomes and social functioning.
The results in some ways are consistent with previous studies and similarly emphasize the dangers of preterm birth. Yet, unlike those studies, which compare preterm infants to unrelated non-preterm infants, the current study also compared preterm infants to their non-preterm siblings and cousins — an approach that made it possible to shed new light on the problem.
“The study has given us insights that no other study has been able to do,” D’Onofrio says.
The sheer number of children in the study allowed the researchers to draw meaningful conclusions on conditions that are relatively rare. For example, birth at 25 to 30 weeks is a rare event, as is autism or schizophrenia. Other studies have not had a large enough dataset to consider such issues simultaneously.
The problem with previous studies that compared preterm infants to unrelated non-preterm infants, D’Onofrio said, “is that preterm birth is associated with a lot of other factors that are also predictive of poor outcomes in the offspring. So you are not sure if preterm birth or all these other factors actually cause these harmful outcomes. Trying to tease apart what is due to preterm birth or everything that goes along with preterm birth is very difficult.”
Comparing siblings is a way of controlling for and holding constant everything those siblings share: mothers and fathers, socio-economic status, and some genetic factors.
“You get the exact same results when comparing differentially exposed siblings and cousins, which suggests our conclusions are very robust,” D’Onofrio said.
When the researchers looked at infant and young adult mortality, the results were the same when comparing siblings as when they compared preterm infants to unrelated non-preterm individuals. Early gestation is associated with greater risk of mortality, suggesting preterm birth has a causal influence. For autism and ADHD, the results are the same with both methods.
In other areas, however, the results are strikingly different from previous findings. The association between preterm birth and severe mental illness, such as schizophrenia or bipolar disorder, was greatly reduced when comparing siblings. Both siblings had higher chances of severe mental illness than the general population. For suicide, the findings are even more dramatic. Although individuals born preterm are more likely to attempt suicide than unrelated individuals who were not born preterm, no distinction exists between siblings.
This suggests, D’Onofrio said, “that part of the association with severe mental illness and all of the association with suicide isn’t due to preterm birth; it is due to something else, something that siblings share.”
The difference occurred again when researchers looked at income. Being born at an earlier gestational age is associated with low income when you compare the individuals born preterm to unrelated individuals born at 40 weeks of gestation. But when you compare siblings, it becomes apparent that the key factor is something else. Factors that siblings share cause the low income.
“Our study is part of a growing interest in research and public health initiatives focusing on very early risk,” D’Onofrio said. “When you look at early risk factors, they don’t just predict one type of problem; they frequently predict lots of problems with long-term implications.”
Exploring how these factors have subsequent ramifications across numerous domains and functions — mortality, physical and mental health, intellectual abilities, social outcomes — is a burgeoning area of research for a problem that is increasingly widespread. According to the World Health Organization, in both developing and industrialized countries, more than one in 10 children are born prematurely, and the numbers are growing.
Co-authors in the IU Department of Psychological and Brain Sciences are research scientist Martin E. Rickert and graduate student Quetzal A. Class; and in the Department of Medical Epidemiology and Biostatistics at the Karolinska Institutet in Stockholm, Henrik Larsson, Niklas Langstrom and Paul Lichtenstein.
The research was supported by grants from the National Institute of Child Health and Human Development, the National Institute of Mental Health, the Swedish Research Council, and the Swedish Prison and Probation Services.
For a copy of the study or to speak with D’Onofrio, contact Liz Rosdeitcher at 812-855-4507 or email@example.com. D’Onofrio is director of the Developmental Psychopathology Laboratory in the IU Department of Psychological and Brain Sciences, which is part of the College of Arts and Sciences.
Preterm Birth and Mortality and Morbidity A Population-Based Quasi-experimental Study
Importance Preterm birth is associated with increased mortality and morbidity. However, previous studies have been unable to rigorously examine whether confounding factors cause these associations rather than the harmful effects of being born preterm.
Objective To estimate the extent to which the associations between early gestational age and offspring mortality and morbidity are the result of confounding factors by using a quasi-experimental design, the sibling-comparison approach, and by controlling for statistical covariates that varied within families.
Design, Setting, and Participants A population-based cohort study, combining Swedish registries to identify all individuals born in Sweden from 1973 to 2008 (3 300 708 offspring of 1 736 735 mothers) and link them with multiple outcomes.
Main Outcomes and Measures Offspring mortality (during infancy and throughout young adulthood) and psychiatric (psychotic or bipolar disorder, autism, attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder, suicide attempts, substance use, and criminality), academic (failing grades and educational attainment), and social (partnering, parenthood, low income, and social welfare benefits) outcomes through 2009.
Results In the population, there was a dose-response relationship between early gestation and the outcome measures. For example,
extreme preterm birth (23-27 weeks of gestation) was associated with infant mortality (odds ratio, 288.1; 95% CI, 271.7-305.5),
Autism (hazard ratio [HR], 3.2; 95% CI, 2.6-4.0),
low educational attainment (HR, 1.7; 1.5-2.0), and
social welfare benefits (HR, 1.3; 1.2-1.5) compared with offspring born at term.
The associations between early gestation and mortality and psychiatric morbidity generally were robust when comparing differentially exposed siblings and controlling for statistical covariates, whereas the associations with academic and some social problems were greatly or completely attenuated in the fixed-effects models.
Conclusions and Relevance The mechanisms responsible for the associations between preterm birth and mortality and morbidity are outcome-specific.
Associations between preterm birth and mortality and psychiatric morbidity are largely independent of shared familial confounds and measured covariates, consistent with a causal inference.
However, some associations, particularly predicting suicide attempt, educational attainment, and social welfare benefits, are the result of confounding factors.
The findings emphasize the importance of both reducing preterm birth and providing wraparound services to all siblings in families with an offspring born preterm.